The original point of view
As Manhattan bursts at the seams, more and more people are traveling to the neighboring boroughs for a more authentic taste of New York City . While many smart travelers will likely want to explore and find their own hidden gems, the ones here are meant to guide the beginnings of a journey into the food delights of New York’s outer boroughs. Pizza is a common theme on this list (it is New York, after all) but one of the beautiful parts of eating outside of Manhattan is the incredible diversity of local eats.
As one of the original melting pots of the U.S.A., New York City has been combining cultures and flavors for hundreds of years. It is continuously evolving, its flavors changing and adapting to the ever-changing flow of newcomers. Food loving New Yorkers have been heading to the outer boroughs for decades, but it is only just starting to grow in popularity for smart travelers.
Each borough is different, with its own distinct feel, look, architecture, history, and food culture. This is the amazing thing about eating your way through the outer boroughs: stepping into them can feel like entering another city, country, and place in time depending on the specific intersection you stand on. In some areas, it will be tough to find people who speak English. In others, the streets may be filled with nothing but small houses. What each borough shares, however, is the ability to provide excellent eateries filled with food from all over the world. Read on to discover a few of the many gems to be found in the Bronx, Brooklyn , Queens, and Staten Island.
The Bronx is one of the most ignored boroughs by tourists. Filled with delicious food, huge parks, and friendly people, it is a great addition for a visit to NYC.
Arthur Ave – This section of Arthur Avenue mainly between E. 184th St. and E. 187th St. is best known for its old school Italian shops and restaurants. It’s the kind of street where you can get bread from a 100-year-old bakery and stop at the multiple generations owned butcher shop next door for the soppressata to go with it. Try the Arthur Ave retail market to start, then head out to the surrounding streets to go down an Italian food rabbit hole.
Seafood in City Island – Another area without a specific eatery suggestion, this one is best accessed via a car, though there are buses that head out this way for those truly dedicated to the cause. A popular weekend spot for New Yorkers to staycation, this little island off the Eastern coast of the Bronx has the quiet charm of old New York mixed with the cheesy fun of a summer party town. Try Johnny’s Reef at the tip of the island for good old fashioned deep-fried seafood baskets with a water view.
No longer even close to fulfilling the label “up and coming”, Brooklyn has become a destination of its own, with many travelers heading right for it over neighboring Manhattan. With its explosive popularity has come the loss of many of the older eateries, but not all. It has also paved the way for new, young chefs to create in a way that is very different from the oversaturated Manhattan Michelin starred scene.
Plan the current version
Use this story as inspiration rather than live operational guidance. Confirm entry rules, transport, opening times, reservations, accessibility, safety advice and local conditions through primary sources close to departure.
Build the day geographically, choose fewer experiences with more time, and prefer people and businesses that add real local context. Details from an archive can start a question; they should not end the research.
Continue with New York City, a Tiplr Smart Destination.
About this archive edition
The historical URL and original publication date are preserved. Advertising, expired promotions, unsupported practical claims and images without a clear rights record were not carried into this edition.

