The original point of view

The Tiplr Community is always ready with great recommendations for amazing places to visit, eat, and drink. That is why I decided to put it to the test and see if our NYC pizza lovers know what they were talking about. I picked six pizza spots highlighted by the Tiplr community, and I took it upon myself to visit all of them.

Tiplr explorer Monty Quaia discovered Roberta’s from The Pizza Show on Vice. As a pizza fan, Monty was looking forward to his trip to NYC, where he had already planned on visiting this gem. He loved the pizza so much that he and his group decided to order another one to share. Roberta’s is far from what anyone would expect a highly acclaimed restaurant to look like. Like Anthony Falco says on The Pizza Show, Roberta’s used to be a mechanic’s shop. Spoiler alert, it still looks like a garage with some picnic tables and a pizza oven. And it’s great! The atmosphere is amazing. Communal picnic tables, ceiling fans, and mostly lit by natural light. The staff is also super friendly.

It was Saturday brunch, and the place was packed. We had a 30-minute wait, but once inside it did not feel crowded, even at the communal picnic table! We ordered two pies for the three of us (we knew we’d be trying out multiple pizza places in one day so… we didn’t want to overdo it). We ordered the Margherita with pepperoni and the Four Emperors. They were both delicious with a thin, crispy crust. The Four Emperors, which was topped with arrabbiata sauce, young pepato, mozzarella, asiago, ricotta and a sprinkling of sesame seeds, was delightfully delicious to me, and a little spicy for my friend.

Famous Ben’s Pizza was written about by The Local , an NYC hostel/hotel. I can totally see why they would recommend it. Famous Ben’s Pizza was easy to get to, with the C and E train just a block away. This is a place where busy New Yorkers stop to have a quick lunch before returning to work.

Famous Ben’s Pizza is a classic NYC pizza shop with a twist. They offer a variety of options not seen on your typical pizza shops. One of these includes buffalo chicken. The slices are big and hearty. I had a slice of their Primavera pizza and the crust and veggies were well seasoned.

Shelter’s pizza was also recommended by The Local. Shelter is located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn , just a few blocks away from the East River. It is also a short walk from Smorgasburg, which is a great place to go for dessert after having brunch at Shelter. The Local recommends trying Shelter’s pizza (obviously), empanadas, and the braised short ribs, I tried two of the three.

Moral of the story here is, check the menu before you head out. Since Shelter markets itself as a “pizza and empanadas lounge”, I assumed I’d be able to try one of their delicious pizzas for brunch, but unfortunately, they only have the margarita available. It was good but certainly didn’t measure up to Roberta’s Margherita. Shelter’s burrata and prosciutto, and ham and peppers were both highly endorsed by our fellow smart travelers, so I’ll have to give them another go, during dinner hours of course.

Plan the current version

Use this story as inspiration rather than live operational guidance. Confirm entry rules, transport, opening times, reservations, accessibility, safety advice and local conditions through primary sources close to departure.

Build the day geographically, choose fewer experiences with more time, and prefer people and businesses that add real local context. Details from an archive can start a question; they should not end the research.

About this archive edition

The historical URL and original publication date are preserved. Advertising, expired promotions, unsupported practical claims and images without a clear rights record were not carried into this edition.