The Peak District market town of Bakewell is a hugely popular place for tourists to visit, both for it's beauty and location in such gorgeous countryside, and for it's world famous sweet, that is, the Bakewell Pudding. If you haven't heard of a Bakewell Pudding, that's because outside of Derbyshire it's more commonly known as the Bakewell Tart. Don't get the Bakewell Tart confused with the iced Cherry Bakewell however, because despite containing many of the same ingredients as it's counterparts, The Cherry Bakewell isn't actually the same. Now, in Bakewell there are at least three cake shops and bakeries claiming to have the recipe for the 'original Bakewell Pudding'.
This is because the pudding's origin has never been exactly clear, and the authenticity brought by the accolade of having the original is a huge sales advantage in terms of the flocks of tourists who make special trips just to try, and buy, the original Bakewell desert. Due to being someone who has insider knowledge because of growing up in the area, I can categorically promise you to know the answer, and even the story. The home of the first ever Bakewell pudding, and also the best place to buy them due to a secret ingredient being passed on through generations only to trusted members of staff, is 'The Old Original Bakewell Pudding Shop', just off the main square in the centre of the town. Around 150 years ago, a cook at the now demolished White Horse Inn deviated, perhaps by mistake, on a recipe for a jam tart, and didn't stir the eggs and almond paste into pastry, but spread it on top of the jam.
This consequently formed a set almond egg custard, which has become hugely popular ever since. This recipe, with it's secret ingredient, has been property of 'The Old Original Bakewell Pudding Shop' ever since. If you go to Bakewell, go and have one warm, with vanilla ice cream or custard, and be safe in the knowledge you're in the only place on earth that can perfectly produce this delicious desert.
