For First time travelers who want to visit a Greek island that will give them a feeling of traditional Greece, in the back of their minds they may feel that the popular islands should be seen, but they are willing to take the chance that they will come to Greece again and see them then. For these people an island like Sifnos is a good choice and one of my two or three favorite islands (along with Kea and Lesvos). Sifnos can be done in combination with Milos (which has spectacular Santorini-like views), and Serifos (which has some of the best beaches in Greece) because there are daily connections and if the ferry gods are smiling upon them they can even get to Santorini. For those people working with Aegean Thesaurus Travel is the best option.
They can book the same hotels in Athens and mainland tours as the other travel agencies but they are located on Sifnos and specialize in these islands. So if you wanted to have an itinerary similar to the popular islands page but experience the elusive 'real Greece' you would replace Mykonos with Sifnos and Santorini with Milos and you would have a holiday with spectacular views, wonderful beaches and great food but with fewer tourists and a much lower price. You can get to Kythnos too which also has some spectacular beaches but the ferry may not go every day. Read more about the Greek islands at: www.greecetravel.com
